Research · Pilot study · November 17, 2026
Who ChatGPT recommends for car accident lawyers: a 10-city study
We asked ChatGPT “Who is the best car accident lawyer in [city]?” in 10 US cities. It named 43 firms, 3 to 6 per city, and justified nearly every pick with a credential it could check on another site. Avvo didn’t come up once.
Key findings
- Third-party credentials drove the picks. Super Lawyers was used to justify a pick in 5 of 10 cities, Doyle’s Guide peer rankings in 4, board certification as a trial lawyer in 4, and Best Lawyers in 3.
- ChatGPT said it discounted advertising. In 7 of 10 answers it said it weighed independent recognition, trial experience or verified credentials over firm advertising.
- Star ratings mattered less than you’d think. In Houston, the top pick’s map card showed a 1.7-star rating. ChatGPT picked it on the strength of Doyle’s Guide and Chambers rankings. Ratings were quoted in the answer text in only 1 city (Nashville).
- Avvo was absent. It wasn’t named or linked in any of the 10 answers. FindLaw came up once.
- Every answer linked at least one named firm’s website, and 5 of 10 linked a state bar or attorney licensing site so the reader could check the lawyer’s license.
Results by city
| City | Top pick | Other firms named | Third-party sources ChatGPT leaned on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa, FL | MattLaw | Abrahamson & Uiterwyk, Distasio Law Firm | Florida Bar board certification, Best Law Firms |
| Atlanta, GA | Butler Kahn | The Champion Firm, The Kalka Law Group | Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers, National Trial Lawyers |
| Houston, TX | Arnold & Itkin | Perdue & Kidd, Sorrels Law, The Ammons Law Firm, Zehl & Associates | Doyle’s Guide, Chambers, board certification |
| Phoenix, AZ | Beus O’Connor McGroder | Breyer Law Offices, Shapiro Law Team, Rafi Law Group, Phillips Law Group | Doyle’s Guide, Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, Expertise.com |
| Chicago, IL | Clifford Law Offices | Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard; Corboy & Demetrio; Power Rogers; Levinson & Stefani | Doyle’s Guide (for all 5 firms) |
| Denver, CO | Zaner Law | Bowman Law, Fuicelli & Lee, Frank Azar | Super Lawyers, published verdicts |
| Charlotte, NC | Brown Moore & Associates | Rosensteel Fleishman, DeMayo Law Offices, Chandler Volta | Doyle’s Guide, Law Leaderboard |
| Las Vegas, NV | Naqvi Injury Law | Valiente Mott, Maier Gutierrez, Benson & Bingham | Super Lawyers, FindLaw |
| Nashville, TN | Ponce Law | Kinnard Law, Jeff Roberts & Associates, Bart Durham Injury Law | Best Lawyers, Law Leaderboard, certified civil trial specialist, Google reviews |
| San Antonio, TX | Pat Maloney Jr. | Michael R. Cowen, Troy A. Brookover, Herrman & Herrman, Brylak Law, DeSouza Injury Lawyers | Texas board certification in Personal Injury Trial Law, Super Lawyers |
Firm names are shown as ChatGPT presented them on November 17, 2026. This is a record of what an AI tool said, not a recommendation of any firm.
What this means for law firms
The firms ChatGPT named had credentials it could verify somewhere other than the firm’s own site. If your attorneys hold board certifications, Super Lawyers selections or peer rankings, make sure they’re stated plainly on your site, linked to the source, and matched to the right attorney and office. If they don’t, those are the gaps worth closing first.
Directory profiles still matter for consistency, but in this test they weren’t what ChatGPT pointed to when explaining its picks.
How we ran it
- Engine: ChatGPT with web search on, default model, Medium thinking effort.
- Prompt: “Who is the best car accident lawyer in [City, State]?” One run per city.
- Cities: Tampa, Atlanta, Houston, Phoenix, Chicago, Denver, Charlotte, Las Vegas, Nashville, San Antonio.
- Date: November 17, 2026.
- What we recorded: every firm named, the top pick, the websites linked and the third-party sources ChatGPT named in its reasoning.
Limits
This is a pilot. It covers one AI engine, one question and one run per city, so it shows patterns, not rankings. AI answers change from run to run, and results can vary by account and location. The full 50-city study will add Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, more case types and three runs per question.
Check your own city
See whether AI names your firm, and who it names instead.
